+- Proxy Community (https://proxycommunity.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Use Case (https://proxycommunity.com/forum/forum-use-case)
+--- Forum: Others (https://proxycommunity.com/forum/forum-others)
+--- Thread: Are Proxy Cards Allowed in Casual Play, or Just for Testing? or What’s the Best Way to Make Hi (/thread-are-proxy-cards-allowed-in-casual-play-or-just-for-testing-or-what%E2%80%99s-the-best-way-to-make-hi)
Pages:
1
2
Are Proxy Cards Allowed in Casual Play, or Just for Testing? or What’s the Best Way to Make Hi - ghostRushX99 - 13-05-2024
"Are Proxy Cards Allowed in Casual Play, or Just for Testing?"
Hey everyone, quick question—what’s the general vibe on using proxy cards in casual play?
I get that they’re great for testing decks before dropping cash, but do folks actually mind if you use them in friendly games? Like, is it cool as long as everyone’s chill, or does it kinda ruin the immersion?
Some of my buddies don’t care, but others get weird about it. Just wanna avoid any awkwardness lol.
Also, do you think it’s different for expensive cards vs. stuff you just don’t own yet? Curious to hear your thoughts!
---
(Or if you prefer one of the other topics, lmk and I can swap it out!)
“” - Swizz99 - 20-07-2024
Totally depends on the group, imo. Some folks treat proxy cards like a crime, while others couldn’t care less.
In my playgroup, we allow proxies as long as you’re testing or saving up for the real deal. But if someone’s proxying a full power-nine deck in a casual game, that’s kinda lame.
Sites like MPCFill can help make decent-looking proxies if you wanna avoid sharpie-on-land vibes. Just keep it reasonable!
“” - vpnHorizonX - 31-10-2024
I’ve seen both sides—some players hate proxy cards ‘cause they feel it cheapens the game, while others just wanna play without dropping $500 on a piece of cardboard.
My rule? If it’s for fun and not tournament prep, who cares? Just ask your group first.
Btw, Cockatrice and Tabletop Simulator are great for testing decks with proxies before committing to buys.
“” - maskedDart99 - 21-02-2025
Honestly, proxy cards are a lifesaver for casual play. Not everyone can afford a Gaea’s Cradle or whatever.
As long as you’re not pubstomping with a fully proxied cEDH deck against precons, most people won’t mind.
Proxying is also great for trying out weird jank before wasting money on a flop.
“” - ObscureOne - 27-03-2025
It’s all about communication. Some folks get salty if you’re running proxy cards without asking, even in casual.
I’d say: “Hey, mind if I test this proxied deck tonight?” solves 90% of issues.
Also, if you’re proxying expensive staples, it’s usually more accepted than proxying bulk rares you’re too lazy to buy.
“” - darkSprintX - 04-04-2025
Proxy cards are fine as long as they’re readable and you’re not being a jerk with them.
I’ve played against sharpie scribbles and full-art custom proxies—both are cool if the game’s fun.
Sites like Deckstats let you goldfish proxy decks online before printing. Super handy!
“” - vpnSprintX - 04-04-2025
My take? Proxy cards are 100% okay in casual if everyone’s on the same page.
But if someone’s against it, respect that. Nothing worse than forcing proxies on someone who hates ‘em.
For testing, I use Moxfield to build and tweak decks before buying. Saves so much cash.
“” - fastWalker99 - 08-04-2025
It’s a mixed bag. Some groups treat proxy cards like cheating, others embrace ‘em.
I’d say: if you’re proxying to keep up with power level, cool. If you’re proxying to pubstomp, not cool.
PrintProxies.com is a solid tool if you want decent-quality proxies for testing.
---
“” - ghostRushX99 - 09-04-2025
Thanks for all the input, everyone! Definitely gonna ask my group upfront next time—seems like communication is key.
Also, didn’t know about Moxfield and MPCFill, so I’ll check those out. Might save me from buying a dud deck lol.
One last Q: anyone have tips for making proxies look decent without a fancy printer? Sharpie life is rough.