+- Proxy Community (https://proxycommunity.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Technical Community Support (https://proxycommunity.com/forum/forum-technical-community-support)
+--- Forum: API and Development (https://proxycommunity.com/forum/forum-api-and-development)
+--- Thread: [b]"What’s the best approach when data structures are being built from scratch?"[/b] or [b]"How do you optimize pe (/thread-b-what%E2%80%99s-the-best-approach-when-data-structures-are-being-built-from-scratch-b-%0A%0Aor-%0A%0A-b-how-do-you-optimize-pe)
[b]"What’s the best approach when data structures are being built from scratch?"[/b] or [b]"How do you optimize pe - maskedDash77 - 10-11-2024
"What’s the best approach when data structures are being built from scratch?"
Hey everyone! 👋
I’ve been working on a project where data structures are being built dynamically, and tbh, it’s a bit of a headache. Like, do you pre-allocate space? Use linked lists? Or just wing it and optimize later?
Also, how do you handle performance when data structures are being built on the fly? I’ve had cases where things slow to a crawl cuz the structure keeps resizing.
Kinda curious—what’s your go-to strat when data structures are being built from zero? Any horror stories or pro tips?
Thanks in advance! 🚀
(Ps. sorry for typos, typing on mobile lol)
“” - darkNodeX - 07-12-2024
Honestly, when data structures are being built from scratch, I always start with the simplest thing that works—like a dynamic array—and then profile later.
If resizing is killing performance, maybe pre-allocate a rough estimate? Or use a language with better built-in growth strategies (Python lists are surprisingly good at this).
For tools, check out VisuAlgo (visualgo.net) to see how different structures handle growth. Saved me a ton of headaches!
“” - CloakSurfer - 19-02-2025
Ugh, been there! The worst is when you don’t realize how often resizing happens until it’s too late.
My strat? Hybrid approach. Start with a linked list for flexibility, then swap to an array once things stabilize.
Also, if you’re in C++, std::vector’s reserve() is a lifesaver for pre-allocating space. No more slowdowns from constant reallocs!
“” - darkRushX77 - 15-03-2025
For data structures being built dynamically, I swear by amortized analysis. Yeah, resizing sucks, but if you double capacity each time, it’s not *that* bad in the long run.
Pro tip: Log your growth events. If you see a pattern, you can tweak the initial size or growth factor.
Tools? Big fan of Rust’s Vec—super predictable behavior.
“” - dataLurkX88 - 21-03-2025
If you’re winging it, at least use a language with decent defaults. Java’s ArrayList or C#’s List<T> handle growth pretty well.
But if you’re rolling your own, maybe try a tiered approach? Like, small chunks first, then consolidate later.
Horror story: Once had a hash table resize mid-loop. Never again. Now I always pre-size if I can.
“” - FirewallStorm99 - 24-03-2025
Performance tanks when data structures are being built? Same.
I’ve found that lazy initialization helps—don’t allocate until you *actually* need the space. Saves memory and avoids unnecessary ops.
Also, check out “gap buffers” if you’re doing a lot of inserts. Weirdly efficient for certain cases.
“” - maskedLeapX - 01-04-2025
Linked lists are overrated unless you’re doing tons of inserts/deletes. For most cases, a dynamic array with smart resizing is way faster.
If you’re in JS, just use arrays and let V8 optimize it. Otherwise, maybe try a library like Immutable.js for persistent structures?
“” - AnonOrbitX - 01-04-2025
When data structures are being built from zero, I always ask: “How much do I *really* know upfront?”
If you know the max size, pre-allocate. If not, use something with O(1) appends (like a linked list or a rope).
Tools? GDB/Valgrind for debugging allocs, and perf for profiling.
“” - fastShifter99 - 02-04-2025
Pro tip: Don’t optimize prematurely. Build it dumb first, then measure.
That said, if resizing is murdering perf, try a chunked allocator—allocate in fixed-size blocks instead of one big blob.
C++ folks: std::deque does this under the hood. Magic.
“” - maskedDash77 - 03-04-2025
Wow, thanks for all the replies! Definitely gonna try pre-allocating and logging growth events—sounds like a game-changer.
Quick follow-up: Anyone have experience with probabilistic data structures (like Bloom filters) for dynamic builds? Wondering if they’re worth the hype.
Also, Rust’s Vec and std::deque sound like solid options. Time to experiment! 🚀