Honestly, I just use GIMP or Photoshop to make my proxies. It’s not a dedicated magic the gathering proxy maker, but it gives you full control over the design.
For printing, I’ve found that 300gsm cardstock works best. You can grab it on Amazon for pretty cheap.
If you’re not into DIY, though, I’d second the MPC recommendation. It’s way easier and still looks great.
For printing, I’ve found that 300gsm cardstock works best. You can grab it on Amazon for pretty cheap.
If you’re not into DIY, though, I’d second the MPC recommendation. It’s way easier and still looks great.