[b]"Where’s the best place to get high-quality Custom MTG proxies?"[/b] or [b]"How do you ensure your Custom MTG p

20 Replies, 991 Views

"Where’s the best place to get high-quality Custom MTG proxies?"

Hey folks! I’ve been diving into the world of Custom MTG proxies lately, and I’m kinda overwhelmed by all the options. Some sites look sketchy, others charge an arm and a leg.

Where do y’all go for yours? I’m looking for something that’s *almost* indistinguishable from the real deal—good cardstock, sharp printing, the works.

Also, any tips on avoiding scams? Seen a few horror stories about folks getting low-res junk or worse, nothing at all.

Appreciate the help!

---

"Are Custom MTG proxies worth it for casual play?"

So my playgroup’s cool with proxies, but I’m torn—should I drop cash on Custom MTG proxies or just print my own janky versions?

I love the idea of having cards that *feel* real, but is it overkill for kitchen table games? Anyone else gone this route and regretted it?

Or maybe you’ve found a sweet middle ground? Let me know!
I’ve had great luck with MPC (MakePlayingCards) for Custom MTG proxies. The quality is insane—like, you’d swear they’re real if you didn’t know better.

Just make sure to use high-res images from places like Scryfall or MTG Pics. Avoid using copyrighted backs if you wanna stay low-key.

As for scams, stick to well-known forums like Reddit’s r/bootlegmtg for trusted sellers.
Yo, if you’re just playing casual, don’t overthink it. I print my Custom MTG proxies at home with a decent printer and some bulk commons + acetone.

Feels close enough and costs pennies. But if you wanna flex, yeah, go for pro stuff.
Check out ProxyKing.biz—they’ve got solid reviews for Custom MTG proxies. A buddy ordered a full EDH deck, and the foiling was *chef’s kiss*.

Just don’t fall for Instagram ads. Those are 99% scams.
Honestly, Custom MTG proxies are worth it if your group’s cool with ‘em. I got mine from Underground Prints, and the cardstock is *thicc*.

No regrets, but yeah, maybe overkill if you’re just testing decks.
OP here—huge thanks for all the recs! Gonna try MPCfill first since y’all swear by it.

Quick Q: Anyone know if they do foil Custom MTG proxies? My inner magpie needs shiny.
For casual play? Nah, save your cash. Use MTG Press to print proxies at home and sleeve ‘em with basics.

But if you’re a collector at heart, Custom MTG proxies from places like Ron’s Proxies hit different.
Avoid Etsy unless the seller has 500+ reviews. Got burned once with blurry junk.

Now I only use MPCfill—you upload your list, and they handle the rest. Quality’s been flawless for my Custom MTG proxies.
If you’re worried about scams, join the Discord server “Proxy Paradise.” Folks there vet sellers and share discount codes.

My last order of Custom MTG proxies was from a guy there—perfect condition, fast shipping.
Custom MTG proxies are 100% worth it if you play a lot. I got tired of swapping cards between decks, so I proxied everything.

Used PrintNinja—kinda pricey, but the colors pop like real cards.



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)