Hey everyone!
So, I’ve been diving deep into building some new decks, but man, some of these cards are just way outta my budget. 😅 I’ve heard about using a magic the gathering proxy maker to print out some proxies for casual play, but I’m not sure which one’s the best.
Anyone got recommendations for a solid magic the gathering proxy maker? Preferably something easy to use and doesn’t make the cards look super fake lol.
Also, if you’ve got tips on printing or where to get good quality cardstock, that’d be awesome too.
Thanks in advance! 🙌
Hey! I’ve been using MPC (Make Playing Cards) for a while now, and it’s honestly the best magic the gathering proxy maker I’ve found. The cards come out looking super legit, and they’ve got a ton of templates for MTG.
Just make sure to use high-res images for the best results. For cardstock, I’d recommend their 330gsm option—feels almost like the real deal.
Also, if you’re looking for a site to grab high-quality card images, check out Scryfall. They’ve got scans of almost every card ever printed.
Yo, I feel you on the budget thing lol. I’ve tried a few magic the gathering proxy maker tools, and my go-to is MTG Print. It’s super easy to use—just upload your decklist, and it spits out printable sheets.
For printing, I just use my home printer on glossy paper, but if you want it to feel more authentic, take the files to a local print shop. They usually have better cardstock options.
Pro tip: double-check the sizing before printing. Sometimes the margins can be off if you’re not careful.
If you’re looking for something quick and free, I’d recommend Deckstats. It’s not a dedicated magic the gathering proxy maker, but it lets you export your deck as a PDF with card images.
Printing-wise, I’ve had good luck with Staples. They’ve got decent cardstock, and you can even get them to cut the cards for you if you ask nicely.
Just keep in mind, proxies are great for casual play, but don’t try to pass them off as real cards at events. 😅
I’ve been using Proxyshop for my magic the gathering proxy maker needs, and it’s been a game-changer. It’s a bit more advanced, but the customization options are insane. You can tweak the art, borders, even the text if you want.
For printing, I’d suggest ordering from a site like PrinterStudio. They’re a bit pricier, but the quality is top-notch.
Also, if you’re into foils, they’ve got options for that too. Just be prepared to wait a bit longer for shipping.
Honestly, I just use GIMP or Photoshop to make my proxies. It’s not a dedicated magic the gathering proxy maker, but it gives you full control over the design.
For printing, I’ve found that 300gsm cardstock works best. You can grab it on Amazon for pretty cheap.
If you’re not into DIY, though, I’d second the MPC recommendation. It’s way easier and still looks great.
Wow, thanks for all the suggestions, everyone! I think I’m gonna give MPC a shot first since a few of you mentioned it. I’ll probably grab some cardstock from Amazon too—300gsm sounds like the way to go.
Quick question though: has anyone tried printing foils? I’m curious if they turn out looking decent or if it’s not worth the extra cost.
Also, big shoutout to whoever mentioned Scryfall for card images. That site is a lifesaver! 🙌
Hey! I’ve been using Card Conjurer for my magic the gathering proxy maker needs, and it’s been awesome. It’s web-based, so no downloads needed, and it’s super intuitive.
For printing, I’d recommend using a local print shop if you can. They usually have better paper options than home printers.
Also, if you’re worried about the cards looking fake, try adding a slight texture overlay in your design software. It makes a huge difference in making them look more authentic.
