Looking for the Best MTG Proxy Maker – Any Recommendations?

20 Replies, 899 Views

Yo, so I’ve been on the hunt for a solid MTG proxy maker lately, and honestly, it’s been a bit of a mess. There’s so many options out there, but half of them either look like trash or cost way too much.

Anyone got a go-to MTG proxy maker they swear by? I’m looking for something that’s decent quality but won’t break the bank. Like, I don’t need *perfect* replicas, but I also don’t wanna be playing with cards that look like they were printed on a toaster, y’know?

Also, if they ship fast, that’s a huge plus. I’m tired of waiting weeks just to get my proxies.

Drop your recs below! Pls no shady sites tho, I don’t wanna get scammed lol.

Thanks in advance!
Yo, I feel you on the struggle to find a good MTG proxy maker. I’ve been using MPC (Make Playing Cards) for a while now, and honestly, they’re solid. The quality is pretty close to real cards, and they’re super affordable if you order in bulk.

Shipping can take a couple weeks depending on where you are, but it’s worth it for the price and quality. Just make sure you use a good template site like MPC Fill to get the right images.

Definitely not shady, and they’ve got a ton of options for customization.
Hey! I’ve tried a few MTG proxy makers, and I gotta say, ProxyKing is my go-to. Their cards are super crisp, and the colors pop really well. They’re not 100% identical to real cards, but they’re close enough that no one will notice unless they’re really inspecting them.

Shipping was pretty quick for me—got my order in about 10 days. Prices are reasonable too, especially if you’re just looking for a few decks.
Bro, I was in the same boat until I found PrintingProxies. Their MTG proxies are legit—great quality, and they feel almost like the real thing. The best part? They ship crazy fast. I got mine in like 5 days, which is a huge win.

They’re not the cheapest option out there, but if you want something that looks good and gets to you quick, they’re worth it.
Honestly, I’ve been using Deckrealm for my MTG proxy needs, and I’m pretty happy with them. The cards look great, and they’re super durable. I’ve shuffled them a ton, and they still hold up.

Shipping took about two weeks for me, but it wasn’t a big deal. Prices are fair, and they’ve got a good selection of templates.
Yo, thanks for all the recs, everyone! I ended up trying MPC based on the comments, and I’m super happy with how the cards turned out. The quality is way better than I expected, and the price was a steal.

I’m curious though—has anyone tried using a local print shop for MTG proxies? I’m wondering if that’s a faster option for smaller orders. Let me know!
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly MTG proxy maker, check out Proxy Nexus. They’re not the flashiest, but the quality is decent for the price. I’ve used them for casual play, and they get the job done.

Shipping can be hit or miss—sometimes it’s fast, other times it’s slow. But if you’re not in a rush, they’re a solid option.
I’ve been using MTG Print for a while now, and it’s been a game-changer. You can print your own proxies at home, and they look surprisingly good if you use the right paper.

It’s not the same as ordering from a professional MTG proxy maker, but it’s super cheap and fast. Plus, you can tweak the designs however you want.
Yo, I’ve had good luck with Black Lotus Proxies. Their cards are high-quality, and they’ve got a ton of options for custom designs.

Shipping was a bit slow for me—took about three weeks—but the quality made it worth the wait. If you’re not in a hurry, I’d definitely recommend them.
I’ve been using ProxyQueen for my MTG proxies, and they’ve been great. The cards look awesome, and they’re super affordable.

Shipping was pretty quick—got my order in about a week. They’re not perfect replicas, but they’re close enough for casual play.



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)